보고 • Board Game Arena

모든 보고

엘 그란데 보고

#58695: "Veto doesn't currently require players to announce their special actions"

confirmed: 개발자가 버그를 확인했습니다

무엇에 대한 보고입니까?

엘 그란데 #235738773

무슨 일이 발생했나요? 아래에서 선택하세요

규칙: 게임 내 규칙이 적용되지 않았습니다

무슨 일이 발생했나요? 아래에서 선택하세요

규칙: 게임 내 규칙이 적용되지 않았습니다

같은 내용에 대하여 이미 등록된 보고가 있는지 확인해주세요

그렇다면, 이 보고를 추천해주세요. 추천을 가장 많이 받은 보고부터 우선적으로 처리됩니다!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

상세한 설명

보고 이력

2022년 Feb 2일 20:45 • bananasplay • 개발자가 아직 버그를 재현하지 않았습니다:

In addition to the card text, the rulebook (p. 10) contains the additional clarifying text for this card:

"Once during this round or the next round, you may entirely or partly prevent another player from executing his special action. You may prevent a special action before or during its execution. The player affected by the Veto must immediately terminate the execution of their special action."

Thus, for the Veto card to be properly implemented, each decision point of an opponent should be logged and "offered" for veto by the holder of the card, such as when multiple caballeros are allowed to be moved. If allowed, the log should simply say "X does not use the Veto card", and the portion of the action should go through.

For cards that allow scoring of multiple regions, such as some of the cards in stack 3, note that p. 11 contains the following rule: "If multiple regions are scored by a single card, the active player chooses the order in which they are to be scored."

The only reason to have this particular rule is for the veto card; otherwise, given that all regions are scored independently of each other, there would be no reason to choose the order of scoring.

For these scoring cards, therefore, the Veto holder should be given the opportunity to use the veto after learning a) whether or not the scoring card is to be activated, and if activated, then b) the Veto holder should be allowed to veto each region, one at a time, as the holder of the scoring card chooses the regions to be scored.

2022년 Feb 2일 22:37 • Volker78 • 개발자가 버그를 확인했습니다:

Yes, the rules are not fully implemented for the veto card, because the code can get very complicated, and hard to get this done. Even the current simple handling is quite hard (btw for some actions you are offered to choose from moves the oppenent makes). So (I can only speak for myself) I won't make the code even more complicated. You may play without veto.

2022년 Apr 2일 23:09 • elieli29 • 개발자가 버그를 확인했습니다:

I know it's far from simple to implement the actual rules related to veto card,.

I hope that considering paragraph 9 of the link at the bottom, it will be feasible to find an implementation simpler of the veto card and closer to the real game experience.

In particular, this sentence:

"You may only use your Veto once, and during the special action is carrying out. You may not cancel an action once carried out."

suggests that no real undo is actually needed, because once an action has been carried out, neither veto card can cancel it.

A straightforward implementation may be this one: when a veto card can be used, each player performing a card action may perform the action that will be "saved" and "showed" (explained in text) to the player with veto card in order to let her/him decide if the action may be taken or not. If not, no more action related to the card played should be performed by anyone.

So it would be like an UNDO on a player X action, selected by the player with veto card.

This will apply also on cards that have "more actions".
For example, considering "move from a region to another one, 2 caballeros of yours,and 2 caballeros of any of your opponents" will be split at most in 4 "steps". Each step will be "saved" and "showed" for approval to the player with veto card. If first step is allowed, then second step can be "saved" and "showed", and so on). As soon as a "step" is blocked, player turn will end and "saved" action will be simply discarded (not applied).

To me, it seems that this way we are satistying paragraphs 9.1 and 9.2.

Paragraphs 9.3 and 9.4 explain the behaviour with special scoring and secret disk.
Since in that case there will be an execution order (chosen by a player or based on the regions or the number of caballeros), the only change is that the UNDO will be applied to the scoring of each region or to each player executing the action established by the card and not only to the action taken by a single opponent.

Hope this help.
Thanks for your work.

boardgamegeek.com/filepage/10182/new-rules-action-cards-confirmed-w-kramerpdf

2022년 Apr 3일 08:59 • Volker78 • 개발자가 버그를 확인했습니다:

I will not take into consideration the linked pdf. Also asking after every move would also be very frustrating for turn-based games, and complicated to program.

2022년 Apr 3일 12:06 • elieli29 • 개발자가 버그를 확인했습니다:

Playing a turn-based games is an additional feature offered by the platform and, IMHO, shouldn't affect the players who wants to play the real-time game.

I mean, to me it seems odd that a rightful rule of the game is not going to be implemented due to the fact that playing a turn-based games will be frustrating.

Nonetheless, if developers think that realise the veto card rule will complicate too much the code, this is a horse of a very different colour.

Thanks.

리포트에 내용 추가하기

여기에 버그를 재현하거나 당신의 제안을 이해하는 데 관련 있는 내용을 아무것이나 남겨주십시오:

다른 테이블 번호 / 수 번호
새로고침을 해서 문제가 해결 되었습니까?
문제가 얼마나 자주 일어났습니까?
만약에 버그에 대한 스크린샷을 가지고 계신다면 Imgur.com 사이트에 업로드 하시고, 여기에 링크를 복사/붙여넣기 하시기 바랍니다.

취소 업데이트 보고

#58695: "Veto doesn't currently require players to announce their special actions"

무엇에 대한 보고입니까?

무슨 일이 발생했나요? 아래에서 선택하세요

무슨 일이 발생했나요? 아래에서 선택하세요

같은 내용에 대하여 이미 등록된 보고가 있는지 확인해주세요

상세한 설명

보고 이력

리포트에 내용 추가하기

보고의 상태를 다음으로 변경:

도움말

기여하기

탐색하기

저희를 팔로우해주세요